SellYourMac Review: Legit Mac Reseller? We Tested It
Selling Apple Devices Through SellYourMac: Our Experience
Selling devices to SellYourMac is straightforward but expect trade-in values below third-party resale prices. Their online configurator provides instant quotes based on model, specs, and selected condition. We tested two devices:
- 2013 MacBook Pro: Quoted $43 (fair market value)
- M1 MacBook Pro: Quoted $223, adjusted to $186 after shipping damage assessment
The process impressed us with transparency. After shipping the M1 MacBook Pro, their technicians emailed detailed photos of newly discovered corner damage—evidence they didn’t cause it themselves. Payment via PayPal was prompt post-acceptance.
Key Consideration: Pack meticulously. While SellYourMac honored our adjusted quote, shipping risks remain. Their communication sets them apart from sketchy trade-in services.
Buy Side Test: Refurbished Device Quality
We purchased four refurbished devices to evaluate quality, pricing, and warranties. Each included OWC’s 90-day warranty (extendable to 1 year for Macs).
iPad 2 (2011 Model) - $43
- Condition: Flawless body, pristine screen
- Performance: Functional but limited to iOS 9.3.5 (most apps incompatible)
- Verdict: Collector’s item only. Not practical for daily use.
Apple TV 4K (A12 Bionic) - $109
- Condition: Heavy scuffs, damaged HDMI port
- Gaming Test: Playable but severe frame drops in NBA 2K26 and Crossy Road
- Verdict: Mediocre value. Buy only if hidden behind a TV.
12" MacBook (2017, i5/8GB) - $329
- Condition: Dead pixel cluster initially, cycle count: 7
- Surprise Fix: Pixel issue vanished after Linux Mint install
- Verdict: Solid with Linux. Avoid macOS on this underpowered hardware.
iPhone XR - $155
- Condition: Good externally, battery at 80% capacity
- Pain Point: No battery health guarantee beyond "≥70%"
- Verdict: Overpriced vs. competitors with 85%+ battery pledges.
2019 Mac Pro (96GB RAM/RX 580X) - $1,229
- Condition: Dents/scratches, but OWC-upgraded RAM
- Performance: Handled 70+ Chrome tabs using 69GB RAM
- Verdict: Outstanding value for creators needing expandability.
Trust Factors: Where SellYourMac Excels and Falters
Transparency is their strength. Device quotes clearly explain adjustments, and their OWC backing adds legitimacy missing from fly-by-night resellers. Weaknesses include inconsistent iPhone battery grading and limited phone inventory.
After analyzing their model, SellYourMac is ideal for selling older Macs or buying refurbished Mac Pros/desktops. Avoid iPhones and iPads unless pricing beats reputable alternatives like Back Market.
Should You Use SellYourMac? Action Steps
For Selling:
- Use their configurator for baseline quotes
- Document your device’s condition with photos/video pre-shipment
- Expect 10-15% lower than eBay prices but faster payout
For Buying:
- Prioritize Mac desktops with OWC-upgraded specs
- Avoid iPhones unless battery health is verified
- Always add the 1-year warranty during checkout
Alternative Platforms:
- Mac Desktops: Apple Certified Refurbished (better warranties)
- iPhones: Back Market (standardized battery ratings)
- Quick Selling: Gazelle (lower offers but no-hassle)
Final Verdict
SellYourMac delivers for its core promise: selling Macs and buying refurbished Mac desktops. While iPhone and iPad deals disappoint, their Mac Pro pricing and repair transparency make them a credible OWC subsidiary. We recommend them for hassle-free Mac trade-ins but suggest cross-checking iPhone/iPad deals elsewhere.
What’s your priority—speed or max resale value? Share your trade-in non-negotiables below!
