title：Aston Vantage vs Ferrari Roma vs Porsche 911 Turbo S: Which Is Best?

content：Which Luxury Sports Car Reigns Supreme?

You’re torn between three of the most desirable luxury sports cars: Aston Martin Vantage, Ferrari Roma, and Porsche 911 Turbo S. Which one delivers the right mix of performance, style, and daily usability? Autocar’s in-depth road test of all three—backed by 129 years of automotive expertise—reveals the answer. After analyzing this video, I believe the narrow winner will surprise you, but all three cars excel in their own unique ways.

Core Specs & Authoritative Testing

Autocar’s test pitted three powerhouses against each other:

Aston Martin Vantage: 656hp 4L V8 (Mercedes-sourced), £165k, rear-wheel drive.
Ferrari Roma: 600+hp 3.9L V8, £185k, rear-wheel drive.
Porsche 911 Turbo S: 641hp 3.8L six-cylinder, rear-engine, all-wheel drive.

Autocar’s track and road tests confirm the Porsche’s 2.7-second 0-62mph time (repeatable without complaint) and the Aston’s status as the cheapest yet most powerful option. These figures are backed by Autocar’s rigorous testing protocols, a standard in automotive journalism since 1895.

Driving Experience Breakdown

Each car offers a distinct personality:

Aston Vantage: Brash and dramatic. Its heavy steering, muscular engine note, and firm ride (softened for British roads) make it feel raw and engaging. The interior’s rotary dials and high-quality materials pass the "tap test" with flying colors, though visibility is limited.
Ferrari Roma: Balanced and elegant. It blends GT comfort with sporty agility. The bumpy road mode smooths out rough surfaces, and the quick gear shifts (via responsive paddles) add joy to every drive. Its high-revving V8 (up to 8,000 RPM) feels refined, not angry.
Porsche 911 Turbo S: Clinical and efficient. Its all-wheel drive delivers unbeatable traction, and the steering is consistent and natural. The cabin is business-like but well-built, with excellent visibility. It’s the least dramatic but most practical of the three.

Which Car Is For You?

Beyond the specs, your choice depends on your priorities:

Aston Vantage: For those who want head-turning style and raw power. Ideal if you crave drama and don’t mind a firmer ride.
Ferrari Roma: For the driver who wants balance. It’s perfect for long trips and spirited drives alike. Autocar’s testers rated it highest for its ability to nail its intended purpose.
Porsche 911 Turbo S: For the practical enthusiast. It’s fast, reliable, and easy to drive daily—even in bad weather.

Toolbox & Action Guide

Immediate Checklist:

Test drive each car on both smooth and bumpy roads to assess ride comfort.
Evaluate interior space and visibility for your daily needs.
Check resale value trends (Porsches often hold value best).
Read Autocar’s full verdict for detailed performance data.

Resource Recommendations:

Autocar Magazine: Get the full 129-year archive and in-depth test results at magazinshop.com/autocar.
Autocar Podcast: Listen to expert discussions on luxury sports cars.
Autocar Website: Stay updated on the latest car reviews at autocar.co.uk.

Final Verdict

The Ferrari Roma takes the narrow win. It balances elegance, performance, and usability better than the others. But all three cars are exceptional—you can’t go wrong with any of them.

Question for You: Which of these three luxury sports cars would you pick for your garage? Share your choice in the comments below!