Top 10 New Costco Finds May 2024: Expert Reviews & Deals

Must-Have New Arrivals at Costco

Costco members know the thrill of discovering new products during warehouse visits. This May brings particularly exciting finds across food, home goods, and seasonal essentials. After thoroughly analyzing the latest product lineup, I've identified standout items that deliver exceptional value while meeting high standards for quality. Whether you're stocking your pantry or preparing for summer, these 10 new arrivals deserve your attention.

Nutrient-Dense Food Discoveries

Kettle & Fire Beef Bone Broth ($19 for 6 packs) offers remarkable value at nearly 50% off typical retail prices. This grass-fed, grass-finished bone broth simmers for 10+ hours, extracting beneficial collagen and gelatin. Unlike standard broths, it contains chondroitin for gut health support. Pro tip: Sip it when feeling fatigued or use it as a base for soups. At roughly $3 per serving, it's significantly cheaper than making homemade broth, which requires hours of cooking and creates strong odors.

Seven Sundays Maple Almond Protein Oats ($9.49) provides 11g protein and 7g fiber per serving from upcycled glyphosate-free oats. The clean ingredient profile—sweetened only with maple syrup and coconut sugar—makes it a breakfast standout. What makes this exceptional is the certification: Most conventional oats contain glyphosate residues, but these meet strict safety standards. I recommend blending the softer pineapple tidbits (mentioned later) into this oatmeal for natural sweetness.

Kirkland Organic Pineapple Tidbits ($12.99) contain just one ingredient: organic pineapple. This is rare among dried fruits, which often contain added sugars, seed oils, or preservatives like sulfur dioxide. While pineapple is naturally high in sugar, these make a smart alternative to candy when you need sweetness. The crispy pineapple chips ($9.99) offer another clean snacking option, perfect for salad toppings.

Almost-Approved & Interesting Options

Chosen Foods Burger Sauce ($8) uses avocado oil instead of inflammatory seed oils—a significant upgrade over fast-food sauces containing corn syrup. Though not fully "Bobby Approved" due to cane sugar, the minimal sugar content (under 1g per tablespoon) makes it a sensible occasional condiment. Important note: Homemade sauce remains healthier, but this is the best store-bought option I've found.

Ivy's Reserve Carbon-Neutral Cheddar ($7.99/lb) presents an intriguing environmental claim, but unanswered questions about farming practices prevent full endorsement. While the carbon-neutral certification suggests sustainable practices, the lack of transparency about cattle feed (GMO vs. non-GMO) or grass-fed status is concerning. Until the company clarifies these details, I recommend opting for Costco's Irish Cheddar, which clearly states "milk from grass-fed cows."

SmashMallows PB&J Snack Bites ($19.99 for 18) show nutritional promise with 4-5g fiber and 5-6g protein per serving. Made with dates instead of refined sugars, they're a better choice than most snacks. However, the oat flour binder isn't organic or glyphosate-free. If you occasionally indulge, these beat conventional snacks, but I can't fully recommend them until the sourcing improves.

Top Home & Seasonal Picks

Stainless Steel Coffee Percolator Set ($40) provides complete non-toxic coffee brewing for camping. The stainless steel construction avoids plastic leaching, unlike most coffee makers. The included carabiner-handle mugs demonstrate clever design. Key benefit: It functions similarly to stovetop Italian makers but serves four people—ideal for summer adventures.

Chefman Glass Electric Kettle ($6 off sale price) features temperature control from 165°F to 212°F—perfect for different tea types. The mostly glass/stainless steel build minimizes plastic contact. I use similar kettles daily for green tea (175°F) and saltwater gargles (165°F). This model outperforms cheaper plastic alternatives that can leach chemicals into hot water.

Reusable Water Balloons (price varies) solve two problems: They prevent melted latex residue on surfaces and reduce environmental hazards to wildlife. Unlike traditional balloons I tried last summer (which fused to my pavers), these simply need gathering after use. Parent tip: They're safer for kids and cheaper long-term than disposable packs.

Safedye Ceramic Storage Set (multi-price) offers non-toxic food storage with oven-safe ceramic bases. While lids contain plastic, the main containers avoid forever chemicals found in plastic alternatives. I recommend hand-washing lids to preserve them. Compared to Costco's glass Snapware, this provides better heat resistance for baking leftovers.

Smart Shopping Strategies

1. Prioritize certified products: Always choose glyphosate-free oats and organic dried fruits when available
2. Check discount stars: Items marked with a * indicate imminent discontinuation
3. Verify claims: Research environmental terms like "carbon neutral" when details are unclear
4. Time your trip: Arrive early for untouched product walls like the bone broth display
5. Compare materials: Opt for stainless steel, glass, or ceramic over plastic when possible

Final Recommendations

The Kettle & Fire Bone Broth and Seven Sundays Protein Oats deliver the strongest combination of nutrition, value, and clean ingredients this month. For home essentials, the stainless steel percolator set and ceramic storage provide lasting non-toxic utility. I'll be monitoring Ivy's Reserve cheese for updates—if they confirm grass-fed practices, it could become a staple.

Which new Costco find excites you most? Share your first purchase plan in the comments—your experience helps other shoppers decide!