2025 Subaru Forester Review: Is the Redesign Worth Upgrading?

content: The Forester's Evolution Tested

As a seasoned automotive analyst who’s tracked Subaru’s evolution for a decade, I recognize the significance of this sixth-generation Forester. When a manufacturer redesigns an icon like the Forester—beloved for its practicality and all-weather confidence—every change matters. Having scrutinized both the specs and firsthand driving impressions from our team (including a fifth-gen owner), I’ll cut through the hype to what truly matters to buyers.

Design Transformation: Bold or Betrayal?

Subaru’s controversial redesign ditches traditional cues for sleeker lines. The sport trim replaces red accents with bronze finishes, while steering-responsive LED headlights create a "shield effect" grille. The roofline now features a steeper rear glass, increasing cargo space to 29.6 cu ft (74.4 folded).

Practicality remains core: Heavy-duty cargo hooks and scuff-resistant headliners address owner pain points. However, the departure from rugged aesthetics raises questions. Natalie’s on-ground observation resonates: "It doesn’t feel Forestery." This design shift may alienate loyalists who cherished its boxy identity, though materials like StarTex upholstery add durability.

Driving Experience: Familiar Yet Refined

Powered by the same 2.5L boxer engine (180 hp/178 lb-ft) and CVT, performance mirrors the outgoing model. After testing Montana backroads, I noted:

• Acceleration remains modest—expect engine roar when pushing hard
• Road noise reduction is significant versus the fifth-gen, a win for highway comfort
• Symmetrical AWD maintains superiority over competitors’ part-time systems

Fuel economy hits 28–29 MPG combined, beating the Hyundai Tucson and Mazda CX-5 but trailing the Nissan Rogue. The unchanged powertrain is disappointing given rivals’ hybrid options, though Subaru confirms a hybrid Forester is imminent.

Tech & Safety Upgrades Analyzed

Subaru’s 11.6" touchscreen (standard except base trim) houses climate controls and X-Mode—a trade-off for tactile simplicity. New safety features shine:

1. Emergency Stop Assist halts the car, alerts EMS, and unlocks doors if driver unresponsiveness is detected
2. Third front camera widens pedestrian/cyclist detection
3. Rear seat reminder prevents child/pet entrapment

Blind-spot monitoring requires a $1,200 package on Premium trim, a notable omission at this price point. Harmon Kardon audio and wireless charging add premium touches, but physical seat heater controls are now screen-based—a step backward for usability.

Value Verdict: Who Should Upgrade?

Pricing increased by ~$3,000 (except Wilderness, up $200). After comparing trims, I recommend:

• Premium trim ($1,900 increase) offers the best value, adding key features without touring’s $40k+ price
• Skip if you prioritize power—no turbo or hybrid yet
• Wait if you own a 2019–2023 model; improvements are incremental, not revolutionary

Key differentiator: The driving feel remains distinctly Forester. Elliot, a fifth-gen owner, confirmed: "Transitioning would feel natural." Subaru loyalists will appreciate refined noise isolation and tech, but design changes may polarize.

Your Essential Upgrade Checklist

Before deciding, verify these in a test drive:

1. Engine noise under acceleration (improved but present)
2. Touchscreen responsiveness during navigation
3. Rear visibility with the steeper rear glass
4. Cargo management with included hooks
5. Passenger space—especially rear legroom

Beyond the Hype: What’s Next

Subaru’s hybrid Forester can’t come soon enough. Rivals like the RAV4 Hybrid dominate this segment, and the current powertrain feels dated. If you need a vehicle immediately, the 2025 makes sense for its safety upgrades and refinement. Otherwise, waiting for the hybrid could yield significant fuel savings.

The bottom line: This is an evolution, not a revolution. Subaru polished the Forester’s strengths without reinventing its character.

"When testing the 2025, I kept thinking: This is what the fifth-gen should have been. The updates are meaningful but not groundbreaking." — Natalie, CarGurus Lead Reviewer

What’s your dealbreaker? Would the missing hybrid option or controversial styling sway your decision? Share your priorities below!