2023 BMW X1 Review: Bigger But Better?

content: Introduction

Is BMW's smallest crossover still the sporty value champion after its 2023 redesign? As Autolist's Editor-in-Chief Dave Undercoffler tested this fully loaded $51,000 example, we analyzed whether the growth in size and price enhances or diminishes the X1's core appeal. After scrutinizing real-world driving footage and specs, I confirm this model delivers a compelling blend of German engineering and everyday practicality. You'll learn whether the base model suffices and how it stacks up against luxury rivals.

Key Questions Answered

• Does the size increase compromise driving dynamics?
• Is the M35i worth the premium over the 28i?
• How does it compare to mainstream crossovers like Honda CR-V?

Redesigned Exterior & Dimensions

BMW's 2023 X1 grows significantly: 1.7 inches longer, nearly 1 inch wider, and 1.7 inches taller than its predecessor. The wheelbase stretches almost an inch, placing it remarkably close to original X3 dimensions. Our M Sport package tester ($2,300 option) features aggressive bumpers, 20-inch alloys, and Frozen Pure Gray Metallic paint.

Critical perspective: While the blacked-out kidney grille and dual exhausts look premium, side-by-side comparisons reveal startling similarities to the new Honda CR-V's silhouette. This raises legitimate questions about BMW's design differentiation at a $20,000 price differential.

Powertrain & Driving Experience

The X1 xDrive28i features a 2.0L turbocharged four-cylinder producing 241 hp and 295 lb-ft torque—gains of 13 hp and 37 lb-ft over last gen. Power routes through a new 7-speed dual-clutch transmission with standard AWD.

Sport Mode Transformation

Base models exhibit noticeable turbo lag in Comfort mode with overly light steering. The solution? Engage Sport mode. This instantly firms steering feedback and sharpens throttle response. On canyon roads, the X1 displays impressive body control and road feedback—characteristics many modern BMWs lack.

Performance verdict: The 28i's power suffices for most buyers. Unless you crave the M35i's 312 hp, save your budget. The base model delivers 90% of the driving experience.

Interior & Practicality Upgrades

BMW's cabin blends luxury and technology with a curved 21-inch display. While Wireless Apple CarPlay/Android Auto integration works well, menu lag frustrates. Climate controls require screen navigation—a regressive step for a luxury brand.

Comfort & Space Highlights

• Best-in-class seats with exceptional bolstering and shoulder support
• Generous rear legroom thanks to sculpted seatbacks
• Cargo area offers a low load floor and increased capacity
• Actual spare tire included—unlike many competitors' inflation kits

Practical note: The deep center console storage risks visibility of valuables when parked. Parents should expect typical compact SUV rear-seat car seat challenges.

Competitive Positioning

Against rivals like Audi Q3, Volvo XC40, and Mercedes GLA, the X1 stands apart with superior driving engagement. While similarly priced, it delivers more authentic BMW dynamics than larger, numb-feeling current models.

Value assessment: Our loaded $51,000 tester approaches diminishing returns. The smarter buy is a base X1 with M Sport package—retaining the essential driving character without excessive luxury markup.

Final Verdict & Recommendations

The 2023 X1 successfully balances growth with retained agility. Its sport-mode transformation validates BMW's driving heritage, while the spacious interior addresses previous practicality complaints.

Actionable Takeaways

1. Test drive in Sport mode to experience the true chassis potential
2. Prioritize M Sport package over luxury upgrades for core BMW character
3. Cross-shop base vs. M35i—the 28i satisfies most drivers
4. Inspect cargo security if street parking regularly
5. Verify climate controls meet your usability expectations

Which competitor would you test against the X1? Share your luxury compact SUV priorities below to help fellow buyers. For new and used listings, explore CarGurus with our expert review insights in hand.