2023 Toyota Highlander Review: Updates, Pros, Cons vs Competitors

content: Is the 2023 Toyota Highlander Still Competitive?

For families navigating the crowded three-row SUV market, the updated Toyota Highlander presents a compelling but complex choice. As an automotive specialist who's spent years evaluating crossovers, I've observed how this segment has exploded with formidable new options like the Honda Pilot and Kia Telluride. Toyota's refresh replaces the V6 with a turbocharged four-cylinder while maintaining the Highlander's signature comfort and hybrid efficiency. After extensive analysis, I'll cut through the noise to reveal whether these changes keep it relevant against newer rivals. You'll get actionable comparisons and learn what this means for your daily driving needs.

Key Changes Under the Hood

Toyota's most significant update involves replacing the previous V6 with a 2.4-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine. Generating 265 horsepower and 310 pound-feet of torque, this powerplant routes through an eight-speed automatic transmission. In practice, the turbo delivers immediate responsiveness. Based on my testing, the torque advantage makes highway merging feel effortless despite the horsepower reduction. However, EPA fuel economy ratings show modest gains: 21 mpg city/28 highway for all-wheel-drive models.

The hybrid variant remains a standout, achieving 36 mpg combined. This efficiency advantage deserves emphasis. While competitors like the Mazda CX-90 offer plug-in options, Toyota's proven hybrid system delivers real-world savings without charging infrastructure dependence. For urban families, this could mean fewer fuel stops during school runs and commutes.

Interior Experience: Tech and Practicality

Inside the Highlander Limited trim, you'll find a thoughtfully designed cabin centered around dual 12.3-inch screens. The infotainment system supports wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. However, during my week-long test, I noticed a significant usability gap. Unlike competitors, Toyota doesn't anchor shortcut buttons when using smartphone projection. This forces extra steps to access climate controls or radio functions.

Physical buttons for climate settings are a welcome relief. As someone who tests dozens of vehicles annually, I appreciate how these tactile controls reduce distraction while driving. The leather seats offer excellent bolstering, with heating/cooling functions that performed reliably during temperature extremes. Storage solutions are practical, including a grippy wireless charger and multiple USB ports.

Space Assessment: Family Reality Check

The Highlander's dimensions reveal a strategic compromise. Measuring smaller than rivals like the Hyundai Palisade, it sacrifices some third-row space for easier maneuverability. In the second row, adults enjoy ample legroom and reclining seats. Clever sliding mechanisms help accommodate rear-facing car seats without blocking third-row access.

The third row works best for children or occasional adult use. At 6'1", I found headroom and legroom tight. Cargo capacity sits at 16 cubic feet behind the third row, expanding to 48.5 cubic feet when folded. While less than some competitors, the inclusion of underfloor storage for the cargo cover demonstrates Toyota's attention to daily convenience.

Competitive Driving Dynamics

On the road, the Highlander's turbocharged engine impresses with minimal lag. The transmission shifts smoothly, maintaining momentum during uphill climbs. Toyota's tuning expertise shows here. Compared to turbo engines in some Volkswagen models, this power delivery feels more linear. However, handling prioritizes comfort over sportiness. The Mazda CX-90 and Honda Pilot offer sharper turn-in for drivers seeking engagement.

Visibility presents a mixed experience. The slim front pillars provide an excellent forward view, but rearward sightlines suffer from thick rear headrests and a small back window. This could affect confidence when reversing in crowded parking lots.

How It Stacks Against Rivals

The refreshed Highlander holds its ground through smart compromises. Consider these critical comparisons:

• Space vs Practicality: The Kia Telluride offers more third-row room, but the Highlander's smaller footprint eases city parking
• Efficiency Leadership: No competitor matches the hybrid's 36 mpg combined in non-plug-in models
• Tech Execution: Physical controls outperform touch-sensitive rivals, though infotainment lags behind Hyundai's intuitive layout
• Value Proposition: At around $50,000 for a loaded Limited, it undercuts premium competitors like the CX-90

Final Verdict and Recommendations

The 2023 Highlander succeeds through balanced execution. Its turbo engine delivers real-world performance exceeding spec sheet numbers, while the hybrid variant remains unbeaten for efficiency. The cabin combines premium materials with ergonomic intelligence, despite some tech quirks.

Key advantages include the hybrid option, comfortable interior, and manageable size for daily use. Notable limitations involve tight third-row space and lack of off-road variants. If maximum passenger room is essential, the Grand Highlander or Kia Telluride deserve consideration. For urban families prioritizing efficiency and ease of driving, this Highlander shines.

Actionable Buyer Checklist

1. Test both powertrains: Compare turbo responsiveness with hybrid fuel savings
2. Measure your cargo needs: Load strollers/sports gear to evaluate the 16 cu-ft rear space
3. Practice infotainment tasks: Try switching from CarPlay to climate controls while parked
4. Check car seat compatibility: Test third-row access with your child seats installed
5. Compare safety tech: Verify Toyota Safety Sense features against Honda Sensing or Hyundai SmartSense

Recommended resources: Consult IIHS safety ratings for crash data, and use CarGurus' comparison tool for real-time pricing. For deeper reliability insights, Consumer Reports' annual survey highlights Toyota's long-term durability advantage.

What's your top priority: cabin tech, third-row space, or fuel efficiency? Share your dealbreaker feature below to help other shoppers.