Dermatologists' Most Repurchased Skincare of 2023

What Dermatologists Actually Finish Using

After analyzing hours of dermatologist content, we noticed a critical gap: most recommendations lack proof of real-world use. That changes today. Dr. Maxfield and Dr. Shah—board-certified dermatologists—reveal their actual empties from 2023. These aren't theoretical suggestions but products they've completely used up and repurchased multiple times. As Dr. Shah emphasizes: "We have access to countless products, so what we finish speaks volumes."

Cleansers: The Surprising Multi-Taskers

La Roche-Posay Purifying Foam Cleanser emerged as Dr. Shah's top empty. He uses it unconventionally: "I use it on my face and body—the lather is rich yet gentle." His clinical insight explains why: "The foaming action efficiently removes oil without stripping skin, ideal for oily types. At 13.5 oz, it delivers exceptional value."

Dr. Maxfield's household emptied CeraVe Hydrating Cleanser repeatedly. He notes: "My wife requests refills constantly. It's fragrance-free and ideal for sensitive skin, though those needing lather may prefer foaming formulas." For acne-prone skin, their household finished multiple CeraVe 4% Benzoyl Peroxide Cleanser bottles.

Moisturizers: Where Texture Reigns Supreme

Eucerin Advanced Repair Cream was Dr. Shah's most repurchased body moisturizer. "It's unsung hero status," he observes. "The formula delivers intense hydration without greasiness—critical for dry climates."

For faces, Skincare Barrier+ Gel Cream was Dr. Shah's frequent empty. "The texture is perfection: lightweight yet substantial. I switch to their richer cream in winter, but this gel suited my combo skin best this year."

Makeup Removers: The Unexpected Staples

Neither dermatologist wears makeup, yet both emptied Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm. Dr. Shah explains: "We use it solely for sunscreen removal. The marshmallow scent enhances the experience, and since it's rinsed off followed by a second cleanser, fragrance concerns lessen." Dr. Maxfield adds: "Its efficacy justifies repurchases—we constantly run out."

Body Cleansers: The Guilty Pleasures

Dermatologists aren't immune to sensory appeal. Dr. Maxfield finished multiple Bath & Body Works Ocean Body Wash bottles. "I know the fragrance isn't ideal," he admits, "but the scent is irresistible." Dr. Shah emptied Tatcha The Deep Cleanse twice—as a body exfoliant. "It breaks all my rules, but the experience justifies it for me."

Shampoos: Where Actives Shine

Neutrogena T/Sal 3% Salicylic Acid Shampoo was Dr. Shah's standout. "It outperforms any clarifying shampoo," he states. "Salicylic acid dissolves product buildup and dandruff without over-drying—a scalp game-changer."

Dr. Maxfield repurchased Nizoral Shampoo consistently. "While residue can be an issue, its antifungal properties make it a staple for scalp health maintenance."

Serums & Treatments: The Strategic Players

Prescription tretinoin and tazarotene topped Dr. Shah's empties. "They're non-negotiables in my routine," he notes. For over-the-counter, Maelys FadeAway Brightening Serum was his most finished product. "It complements my prescription regimen. The mix of brighteners tackles dark spots effectively, though witch hazel inclusion is puzzling."

Sunscreens: The Daily Essentials

Dr. Maxfield's household repeatedly emptied Supergoop Glow Screen. Dr. Shah lamented finishing La Roche-Posay UVMune 400 (only available in Europe): "Its advanced filters highlight how outdated U.S. sunscreen regulations are." His accessible repurchases included EltaMD UV Restore and La Roche-Posay Anthelios Mineral Tinted.

The Non-Skincare Staples

Hanz de Fuko Claymation Hair Paste was Dr. Shah's most repurchased item ever. "After 5 years and hundreds tested, nothing holds my straight hair as well." Dr. Maxfield finished countless Yasso Greek Yogurt Bars: "At 100 calories, they're my guilt-free dessert solution."

Actionable Takeaways From Derms' Empties

1. Match cleansers to skin needs: Foaming for oily (LRP), non-foaming for dry (CeraVe Hydrating)
2. Prioritize texture in moisturizers: Gels for combo skin (Skincare), creams for very dry (Eucerin)
3. Use salicylic acid shampoo weekly to clarify scalp and hair
4. Layer dark spot treatments: Prescription (hydroquinone/tretinoin) + OTC multitaskers (Maelys)
5. Apply sunscreen to hands after driving to prevent "car-door stains"

"Your empties reveal your true routine," says Dr. Shah. "Mine show I prioritize efficacy, texture, and sensible indulgence." What product have you actually finished this year? Share your most repurchased item below—we'll analyze common themes in a future piece.