Friday, 6 Mar 2026

Kia Telluride vs Subaru Forester Off-Road Test Results

Kia Telluride X-Pro vs Subaru Forester Wilderness: Off-Road Showdown

After analyzing Edmunds' trail test footage, I can confidently say both vehicles surprised us with their capabilities. The core question we're answering: Do factory off-road packages actually enhance trail performance or are they just cosmetic upgrades? Through sand washes, articulation tests, and steep hill climbs, we discovered where each vehicle shines and where limitations appear.

Testing Methodology and Vehicle Specs

Edmunds conducted controlled tests using:

  • 2023 Kia Telluride X-Pro: 291HP, 8.4" ground clearance, center differential lock, all-terrain tires
  • 2023 Subaru Forester Wilderness: 9.2" ground clearance, X-Mode terrain management, front skid plates
  • Reference vehicle: Ford Bronco (true off-road benchmark)

The testing included five critical obstacles: deep sand washes, articulation "ziggurat" tests, whoops sections, traction-limited climbs, and steep hill ascents. What stood out immediately was how the Wilderness package offered genuine mechanical enhancements like transmission coolers and optimized drive modes, while the X-Pro focused more on aesthetic upgrades.

Terrain Performance Breakdown

Sand Wash Capability

Kia Telluride X-Pro:

  • Leveraged its 291HP engine effectively
  • Maintained momentum with tires at 19 PSI
  • Longer wheelbase provided stability but reduced maneuverability

Subaru Forester Wilderness:

  • Shorter wheelbase allowed nimble navigation
  • X-Mode's sand setting optimized power delivery
  • Lacked low-end torque compared to Telluride

Key finding: The Telluride's power advantage gave it a slight edge in deep sand, though both performed admirably. This demonstrates how horsepower matters more than size in loose terrain.

Articulation and Approach Angles

The "ziggurat" test revealed critical differences:

| Vehicle          | Approach Angle | Steps Cleared |
|------------------|----------------|--------------|
| Subaru Forester  | Improved       | 2 steps      |
| Kia Telluride    | Limited        | 0 steps      |

The Forester Wilderness conquered two steps thanks to its 9.2-inch ground clearance and redesigned bumpers. The Telluride immediately scraped its front end, exposing its grocery-store approach angles. This proves Subaru's Wilderness package delivers functional geometry improvements while Kia's X-Pro prioritizes road manners.

Traction and Hill Climbing

Muddy incline test results:

  • Forester used X-Mode to find traction despite wheel spin
  • Telluride initially failed until switching to Snow Mode
  • Both ultimately succeeded on the steep hill climb

Critical insight: The Forester's shorter wheelbase helped maintain contact on uneven terrain, while the Telluride's length became a liability on the initial climb. However, the Kia's power advantage proved decisive on the steepest gradient.

Real-World Value Assessment

Subaru Forester Wilderness:

  • Pros: True mechanical upgrades, best-in-class clearance, functional skid plates
  • Cons: Cabin shudder on rough terrain, limited power
  • Ideal for: Forest service roads, snowy conditions, moderate trails

Kia Telluride X-Pro:

  • Pros: Luxurious ride quality, powerful engine, highway comfort
  • Cons: Minimal approach/departure angles, limited articulation
  • Ideal for: Gravel roads, beach driving, light trail use

The verdict: Subaru's Wilderness package delivers authentic off-road enhancements justifying its name. Kia's X-Pro excels as a comfort-focused all-road package rather than true off-road equipment. Neither replaces a dedicated 4x4, but the Forester comes closer to its advertised capabilities.

Actionable Buyer Advice

  1. Evaluate your actual needs: 95% on-road driving? The Telluride's comfort outweighs its trail limitations
  2. Check tire specifications: Both benefited significantly from proper air-down techniques (19 PSI)
  3. Prioritize skid plates if exploring rocky terrain - the Forester's protection proved valuable
  4. Test approach angles with a simple curb before purchase - our ziggurat test exposed real limitations
  5. Consider resale value: Wilderness trim holds stronger appeal among outdoor enthusiasts

Tool recommendations:

  • Tire Deflators (e.g., Staun): Essential for safe air-downs
  • Trail recovery boards: Helpful for both vehicles in sand/mud
  • OnX Offroad app: Best for finding appropriate trails matching your vehicle's capability

Final Verdict

After scrutinizing every test segment, the Subaru Forester Wilderness demonstrates meaningful off-road engineering that justifies its adventure branding. The Kia Telluride X-Pro delivers exceptional on-road refinement with limited but respectable trail ability. Choose the Forester if you regularly encounter challenging terrain; opt for the Telluride if you prioritize daily driving comfort with occasional dirt-road excursions.

Which capability matters more for your adventures - ground clearance or cabin comfort? Share your priority in the comments below.

Youtube
Blog→